Blog

Or search support forum

What's Global Moxie?

Global Moxie is the hypertext laboratory of Josh Clark, a writer, programmer and designer whose projects include the Big Medium web content management system. Josh spins words and code from his multimedia studio in Paris, France.

What's Big Medium?

Big Medium is flexible, easy-to-use server software for creating and editing websites directly from your browser. Check out the features or download now.

On Shelves

Cover: Best iPhone Apps

Best iPhone Apps is my guide to more than 200 gee-whiz apps to unlock the full potential of your favorite gadget. Order yours now.

iWork ’09: The Missing Manual

iWork ’09: The Missing Manual is my fun and comprehensive book about Apple’s remarkable word processor, presentation software, and spreadsheet program.
Order yours now.

Moxiemail

Enter your e-mail to receive occasional updates:

Winning the Uphill Battle

Posted Oct 17, 2008

Vélib
Parisians and their Vélib bikes. Photo by stttijn.

As any of my friends will confirm, I’m pretty much obsessed with Vélib, the public bike-sharing system here in Paris that makes it super-convenient to zip around the city on two wheels. It also gets my geek on: Vélib is a complex system that neatly tucks away its complexity behind a simple interface and some clever behavioral incentives.

Here’s how Vélib works: There are over 20,000 bikes distributed among 1,500 stations throughout the city. Pick up a bike from one station, return it to another. You purchase a daily, weekly or annual subscription, which allows you to ride the bike as much as you like in 30-minute chunks. The bikes aren’t for leisure rentals; they’re intended to be used for quick, direct one-way trips of 30 minutes. You have to pay for longer trips, and overage fees add up quickly.

As you might expect, these one-way trips are not evenly distributed throughout the city at certain hours. Bikes tend to clump in some areas and empty out in others. To address this, workers circulate in trucks, moving the bikes from full stations to empty ones.

It turns out that this is an uphill battle. Literally.

See, Paris has a handful of steep hills. The Montmartre neighborhood, for example, is perched at the top of a rise some 450 feet above the Seine. Taking a bike down the hill has a certain obvious appeal, but riding back up to the top... not so much.

The uphill penalty is financial as well as physical. The hills are at the outer edges of the city, so the extra time to get up a hill for trips from the city center can easily nudge you over the 30-minute free period. It can cost money to ride a Vélib bike up the hill. The result: In Vélib’s first year of service, bike stations in Montmartre were always empty. The brute-force method of moving bikes by truck couldn’t keep up.

Over the summer, though, the good people of Vélib added a simple behavioral incentive to the system: Return your bike to one of 100 stations perched over 60 meters above the rest of the city, and 15 minutes of free riding is added to your account.

Sonic and bike
Riding uphill is now a power-up.

They turned a hassle into a game, pain into points. Riding uphill is now a power-up. The free minutes are a bonafide reward, too, saving money on destinations that are often outside of the free 30-minute radius. More bikes make it back up the hill. Since the program was launched in June, over nine years of bonus minutes have been awarded.

As a software developer, I obsess over performance bottlenecks, inefficient areas of code that bog down the rest of the application. It turns out that the best solution often isn’t a brute-force route through the problem (“let’s truck the bikes up the hill”) but rather an elegant sidestep around the issue (“how can we get the riders to do it instead?”).

So the systems guy in me loves this solution, but even more, it appeals to something more playful. I love that this simple tweak made an uphill commute feel more like a game, where you earn points and reward for your effort. It reminds me of Jane McGonigal’s spirited encouragement to do more to “make the real world more like games,” which I wrote about a few months ago:

Her idea: By introducing game-like systems into our work and home lives, we can imbue otherwise tedious tasks with the spirit of reward and collaboration that makes gameplay fun. Jane pointed to a game called Chore Wars which turns housework into gameplay for families. (“Finally you can get experience points for housework!”) She also pointed to the Nike+iPod gizmo that transforms running into a community video game.

Vélib fixed a performance bottleneck by introducing a game into the system. What’s not to love?

Tags: , , , ,

Want more? Recent blog entries...

Comments

7 comment(s) on this page. Add your own comment below.

Oct 17, 2008 11:43pm [ 1 ]

Haha...that is awesome. I'm glad they came up with a better solution than trucking the bikes up the hills, seems to sort of defeat the purpose of introducing the bicycles into the transportation system if they're going to continuously run trucks around the city moving bikes around.

I often make games myself when riding my bike around. Make that green light or pass that car (or x number of cars!) sort of trials. I'm still a bit confused why someone would sign up for the bike rental instead of just buying a used bicycle. What are the benefits of renting versus buying? Seems it'd be a lot cheaper to just pick up a used bicycle for $200-$300.

Oct 18, 2008 12:31am [ 2 ]

It's hard to overstate just how incredibly popular the Vélib system is here. The bikes are in heavy rotation, and the system has been a big success.

Me, I'm a big fan of not having to own and store the bike, and I particularly like that I can pick up a bike from anywhere in the city and drop it off wherever I like. I basically have an instant bike whenever/wherever I want it. I frequently do one-way trips and find other transportation for the other direction. If it starts raining, I'm not committed to taking a bike on the return. No worries about theft or security. It's really convenient. And cheap, too: The annual subscription is just 29 euros.

Oct 23, 2008 12:21am [ 3 ]

I agree with Josh -- it can be inconvenient to be responsible for a bike throughout the day. There is too much bike theft, at least in our area near and in Chicago and we don't take bikes anywhere unless we'll be able to store them securely. This program eliminates that barrier to bike use.

The suburban bus system here, Pace, has bike racks on the fronts of its buses. It would seem to defeat the purpose, but they are a godsend. If you have to juggle two bus lines, for example, you can ride to your second stop without having to leave the bike "locked" outside. If your commute is just a little too long on the bike the bus can get you halfway there, or can get you past unsafe road to where it's safe to bike.

Jeff Turmelle
Oct 23, 2008 9:02pm [ 4 ]

Bonnie makes a good point. The first thought I had was what about bike theft. Its a big problem in New York City. If they don't get your bike, they end up stealing the pedals or brakes or seat... Barring that, it sounds like a great system. I wish they had it here in NY for the same reasons that Josh loves it in Paris.

Oct 23, 2008 9:44pm [ 5 ]

Vélib definitely has to cope with light vandalism, but I'm not under the impression that theft is a big problem. The bikes are hard to steal; they lock into sturdy posts at the Vélib stations (you release them by swiping your card, which checks the bike out to your account; they have your credit card and bank info if the bike never comes back). The seats are supposedly theft-proof, although you occasionally see some bikes where a crafty vandalist has somehow managed to get a seat off. More frequently, you see bikes where the basket or bell has gone missing.

The bikes are custom-designed for this system, and they're built for war. That makes them a bit heavy, but man, they can stand up to abuse. After a year, the fleet is in surprisingly good shape. But you definitely learn a routine before taking a bike out (check the tires, chain, seat adjustability, basket, bell, lights, brakes).

wes
Apr 10, 2009 11:03am [ 6 ]

I like the around the house idea... I'll let that idea marinate.

The key in the biking system was reducing someones expenses...at least that was the carrot... so what is the stick around the house? Paying for laundry and housekeeping..... the eye sores of stacking up dishes.... the unfluffed pillows on the couch..... that new funghi growing on the bottom of the bathroom door ( none of these are examples from my house;) ) . Those are the "costs" or "sticks" for me. But they are not the sticks for other family members..... more complex now isn't it. getting back to work now.

Oct 8, 2009 2:49pm [ 7 ]

Not sure if you'll welcome this comment here, feel free to delete if you don't like my "advertising" as it were on your site.

I've written a small site designed for iPhones that tells you where the nearest Vé'Lib stations are and how many bikes / free spaces there are at each : it's at http://velib.sapir.fr and you can comment on it at http://sapir.fr/talk if you have any feedback.

I personally use the Vé'Lib system obsessively and wrote the site because I was tired of now knowing which way to walk near my home to either pick up a bike or drop it off !

Cheers.

Add a Comment

Don't be shy.

(Use Markdown for formatting.)

This question helps prevent spam:

Download Big Medium
Try it free for 30 days, or buy to unlock.

State of Josh's Brain

Hanging

Austin, TX

Map of Josh's current location

Snapping

Latest photos