Blog

Or search support forum

What's Global Moxie?

Global Moxie is the hypertext laboratory of Josh Clark, a writer, programmer and designer whose projects include the Big Medium web content management system. Josh spins words and code from his multimedia studio in Paris, France.

What's Big Medium?

Big Medium is flexible, easy-to-use server software for creating and editing websites directly from your browser. Check out the features or download now.

On Shelves

iWork ’09: The Missing Manual

iWork ’09: The Missing Manual is my fun and comprehensive book about Apple’s remarkable word processor, presentation software, and spreadsheet program.
Order yours now.

Moxiemail

Enter your e-mail to receive occasional updates:

Paper Cup? Five Bucks, Please

Posted Mar 25, 2008

Overheard in the line for coffee at the Austin Convention Center at SXSW earlier this month...

Customer: Could I just get an empty cup?

Cashier: Yeah, but I have to charge you for a coffee. That’s $2.75.

Customer: For a paper cup?

Cashier: (Embarrassed.) I know, but they count the cups, so we have to sell the cups at full price. Basically, we sell cups.

Customer: (Sighs.) Okay, fine, I’ll pay for it. I’ll take the small cup.

Cashier: (Uncomfortable. Glances back at the manager.) The small cup is for our specialty coffees, so that one is $4.75.

Customer: The small cup costs $2 more than the large cup? $4.75, just for an empty paper cup?

Cashier: (In obvious pain.) I know. Sorry, there’s nothing I can do.

Trapped

Both the cashier and customer were trapped by the coffee stand’s dubious accounting system (the number of cups apparently have to match up with the amount of cash in the till). Want a cup? Five bucks.

“We sell cups.” Well, no, they don’t; that’s just how the (coffee) bean counters see it. To customers, they sell coffee, and the cup is just an incidental vehicle, zero value. The imposition of this lame internal system on the actual transaction allowed no flexibility or judgment on the part of the cashier, and turned the real-world expectations of the customer upside down. Frustration on both sides of the counter.

It struck me as a useful reminder for interactive designers and developers: For customers, the end experience is way more important than how things work under the hood. How does my code-based view of software and site design seep into my interfaces to conflict with users’ goals or expectations? What kind of dopey trade-offs or ridiculous conundrums do I unintentionally impose?

Experiences should be tailored to the customer’s understanding of the task at hand. How it actually works behind the scenes should be invisible. It’s about the coffee, not the accounting.

Tags: , , , , ,

Want more? Recent blog entries...

Comments

2 comment(s) on this page. Add your own comment below.

Anonymous
Mar 25, 2008 4:26pm [ 1 ]

Dang, I like this analogy.

Sep 2, 2008 4:31pm [ 2 ]

That's pretty sad... But it happens a lot in our industry! Especially when you get designers who can't program...or programmers who can't design.

Add a Comment

Don't be shy.

(Use Markdown for formatting.)

This question helps prevent spam:

Download Big Medium
Try it free for 30 days, or buy to unlock.

State of Josh's Brain

Hanging

St-Paul, France

Map of Josh's current location

Snapping

Latest photos